Forum

You must be logged in to post

 
Search Forums:


 




open post to admin…?

UserPost

7:09 pm
05/13/2009


kingawol

Gold User

kingawol

posts 466

1

well i was wondering about admin's policy regarding forums…

i don't understand what it is that gets some topics locked or deleted.

tbh , its the quality of the people on this site that attracts me here , as you must be aware that other sites post trophy lists before you do , so i'd like to know why?

why did you let the Lets Talk thread go out of hand with crazy theories but lock a topic like Domba-Car 's 'Hello' ? i must say i'm confused , why not just delete the Off Topic section altogether if you don't want this type of 'chat' thread to develop. i would have imagined you'd enjoy having people on your site this regularly though.

fair enough , this isn't a chatroom , but i would have thought you'd enjoy having created a type of community around here that is not present on other such sites. after all , just like with the Trophy List threads , people have the choice to go into a forum or not.

just want to know so i can figure whether or not this place still is of any interest to me.

ps. i'm still be thankful for your work regardless of that…

i smoked the pot that called the kettle black.

7:18 pm
05/13/2009


Atomic-G

Silver User

London, uk

posts 310

2

i know what you mean also he should unlck the lets talk thread since killer has gone and he was the only one who was arguing so i dont see no point of it still being locked and i personaly think admin should let people who he trusts and goes on the site near enough everyday to run it aswell since its got to be hard running all this on person

Pain is weakness leaving the body.

7:25 pm
05/13/2009


kingawol

Gold User

kingawol

posts 466

3

i understand he runs the site , and that the Lets Talk thread had stuff people could find insulting.

but some others had nothing but jokes in them and got deleted…or locked. i'd just like to know what admin deems acceptable for HIS site . then i can decide if that suits me. but it is HIS site.Laughing

i smoked the pot that called the kettle black.

7:46 pm
05/13/2009


Tridon

Gold User

Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada

posts 448

4

Well, since I have started two threads that have been deleted and/or locked, I figured I'd get in on this.


First off, this is a great site. It has helped me immensely in completing games and figuring out trophies. The help that this site gives PS3 owners was my original reason for coming here. For that, I would like to give a huge thanks to the Admin. I can't imagine how much work goes into this site and for the fact that he does this is on his own time with his own money is highly generous. So Mr. Admin, thank-you.


Now, as for the discussion at hand, I can understand that you don't want this to be a chat room. That is fine. However, when you have a section titled “Off Topic” and someone makes a thread in that section that is off topic where nothing wrong is happening and everyone is having fun, why close it? Is that not what “Off Topic” is for? My reason to be on here everyday is to interact with the wonderful community of people that have gathered under you on your site and forum. I've seen arguments, insults and racial slurs on here in threads that have lasted longer than one that is full of friendly banter and jokes. That to me doesn't make much sense. Is it because of your “Bronze/Silver/Gold” system on here that you don't want continuous posts from members? If that's the case, why not just let that system go? I honestly have never paid any attention to it. I just find fun to joke around with everyone.


If chatting through threads is really such a big problem, is there anyway a chat room could be added to the site? This would keep the community around and happy at the same time. I for one don't want to go to any other sites because, like I've stated in an earlier thread I created, this site really does have the best bunch of people I have ever seen.


I'm not trying to attack you here or anything because I REALLY do respect the work you do around here. However, a breakdown of what each section contained within your forum is for would be appreciated. I mean, when you look at all the sections, half of them almost seem like they're for the same topics. I can see why new people on here (which I relatively still am) would get confused of where and what to post. I don't want to go anywhere else but if this forum is going to be so tight-knit and 'hush-hush', I may have to. Thanks, Admin!

Tridon’s PS3 Collection http://www.blu-ray.com/community/collection.php?member=tridon&ps3=1

7:48 pm
05/13/2009


kingawol

Gold User

kingawol

posts 466

5

glad to see i'm not the only one that feels that way.Laughing

i smoked the pot that called the kettle black.

8:00 pm
05/13/2009


BigWoopMagazine

Gold User

posts 962

6

I'm new here, and was wondering myself what the rules are.  I seem to get away with cursing quite a bit (I don't try to, I'm just naturally foul mouthed).  But I have gotten my topics locked on other sites quite easily (one in particular, I was on sony's site and compared ps3 to xbox, and immediately got locked out), and would prefer to know whats cool and whats not so my disussions don't get ended that way.

“I can wire anything to anything! I’m the Professor!” -The Professor

9:05 pm
05/13/2009


Knoxie

Platinum User

Newcastle, England

posts 2219

7

yeh same here, i wanted 2 post in that 1 word game but i didnt get a chance! it looked mint as well!

Ohhhhh Coloccini, when you captain The Mags, oh Coloccini, you will get plenty of shags, oh Coloccini, my mam’s joining the queue! (8) … PSN – NuFc_kNoXiE_KiLa … XBL Gamertag – iNUFC iKnoxie

9:07 pm
05/13/2009


Domba_car

Gold User

Croatia

posts 817

8

yea, why did he lock my Hello?? by the way you can just write Domba's

There must be more to life than sitting wondering if there is more to life. Current status: Waiting for my Slim.

9:24 pm
05/13/2009


PS3 Trophies

Admin

Cold North

posts 782

9

I try not to lock threads too often, out of 700+ threads there's just a handful that has been locked. It's only when they get way off topic (And yes a thread can get off topic even if it's located in the “off topic” section ;) ) or contain posts people might find insulting.

At the moment “one word games” and similar threads are treated as “post boosting” threads. Even if that wasn't the intention of the creator of the thread.

I'll look into adding a forum (or some kind of chat) just for word games and extremely off topic chatting where posts aren't counted. There you can go bananas if you wish :)

9:29 pm
05/13/2009


kingawol

Gold User

kingawol

posts 466

10

ok , fair enough , but most of us dont really care about post boosting…Laughing

so adding a Community Chat section could be cool.

i smoked the pot that called the kettle black.

10:14 pm
05/13/2009


parnakas

Member

Ontario, Canada

posts 3889

11

i cant believe i missed out on the 1 word game……

but if admin adds a community chat section… holy crap..this site will be even better!!!

“Pull the pins, Save your grace. Mark these words, On his grave.” …………….. - The Mars Volta: Televators

10:21 pm
05/13/2009


Tridon

Gold User

Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada

posts 448

12

PS3 Trophies said:

I try not to lock threads too often, out of 700+ threads there's just a handful that has been locked. It's only when they get way off topic (And yes a thread can get off topic even if it's located in the “off topic” section ;) ) or contain posts people might find insulting.

At the moment “one word games” and similar threads are treated as “post boosting” threads. Even if that wasn't the intention of the creator of the thread.

I'll look into adding a forum (or some kind of chat) just for word games and extremely off topic chatting where posts aren't counted. There you can go bananas if you wish :)


A “Community Chat” would be much obliged, good sir. Oh, and for the record, “post boosting” for never, ever an intention of mine. Smile

Tridon’s PS3 Collection http://www.blu-ray.com/community/collection.php?member=tridon&ps3=1

1:23 am
05/14/2009


Pokenny

Gold User

Portsmouth, England

posts 583

13

I made that one word game thing because I thought it would be cool and funny. Why did you lock it? Was their any need? No one cares about ‘post boosting’ and even if we did care about post boosting… Why do you care if people do? As long as it is in off topic, it should be fine…

Gamufi – What I want to do now is grow my beard really long, weave it into my pubes and strum it like a harp. – Bill Bailey

2:05 am
05/14/2009


ShadeBlack

Platinum User

England

posts 1735

14

here's an idea for the admin.


On another forum i go to, they have a spam section where people post anything and everything.  The good thing about it though, is that the posts in that section don't count towards your total post count.


perhaps you can change the off-topic posts do this?  this would resolve the post-boosting issue that nearly every forum faces.

as for the others, I accept that there will be some threads you will close.  And I'm not about to argue either!


I think people are being a tad bit harsh on the Admin here at the moment.  he's closing threads because he deems them unsuitable for the site.  it's his decision to do this, and I don't think anyone should try to change his mind.

A dirge for her, the doubly dead, in that she died so young. ~Edgar Allen Poe

5:02 am
05/14/2009


Hypnosis

Silver User

Joey Badafuco ova heeeeerrre!

posts 348

15

Yea i never understood why people would boost their post count. Its not like you get anything special for having high amount of posts. It doesnt say to anyone that “wow he must know what he is talking about,he has 1000 posts” Regular visitors to a site know who the people are that know what they are talking about and the people who are most helpful, regardless of post count.

Just my opinion.

For the record. Although the one word game was fun. I am really suprised it lasted as long as it did. Also the Hawx:team deathmatch thread. What was up with that one? I went in there not expecting to find another one word game,but there one was lol.

Keep up the great work on the site Admin.Smile

11:33 am
05/14/2009


Pokenny

Gold User

Portsmouth, England

posts 583

16

Mr Admin, no disrespect to you… But in your words…
Off Topic
‘Anything goes here’

Now I don’t mean to pick an arguement but surely if anything goes there then nothing is off topic in off topic (if that makes sence).

Now I did look as I always do when I come to any forum for a sticky ‘Rules’ post, like no swearing or star out your swaering. Correct grammer and puntuation and so on. Before you comment on my spelling I am deslixic(sp?) and I did say grammor. Maybe before locking or deleting threads you should make some rules.

OK fair enough about insulting post and non ‘pc’ comments, but some people don’t know any better and becasue their is no rules to state that common sence applies here as evidently some people can’t seem to realise that when they post something offencive that it actually offends people. If you had a rules page, after you deleted their comment, you could send them a PM with the link to the rules to them. Then if they continue to offend and ignore the rules then their ban I.P.

Just a thought…

p.s. If you make a ‘non post counter’ forum, can you unlock my one word story thread and move it to it please.

Gamufi – What I want to do now is grow my beard really long, weave it into my pubes and strum it like a harp. – Bill Bailey

1:19 pm
05/14/2009


kingawol

Gold User

kingawol

posts 466

17

you know what ? eff it i'm too bloody old to bother with a set of silly rules .

bye. those that know me can find me on psn. 

i smoked the pot that called the kettle black.

 
 

About the All PS3 Trophies forum

Most Users Ever Online:

80


Currently Online:

22 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4

Forums: 41

Topics: 2759

Posts: 58346

Membership:

There are 8697 Members

There has been 1 Guest

There is 1 Admin

There are 0 Moderators

Top Posters:

parnakas – 3889

CoryAllen – 2701

Knoxie – 2219

gow2rules – 1821

emdeepee – 1797

ShadeBlack – 1735

Administrators: PS3 Trophies (782 Posts)